Like a Power Rangers villain sprung from a space dumpster, the cold weather has released me back into my natural state. Winter is coming. That means I can eat more, wear bigger coats, and hide the evidence. You need something thick to get you through the season. So naturally, I went back to Golden Steer.
There’s a nice bit of synergy here, too. The last time I went, it was the final day of the old fall and winter menu. Now I’m back for the new one. Full circle. Full stomach.
This post is a little late. Life has been busy. And to be completely honest, I could not get a good photo half the night. I’m surprised the photos look remotely presentable. If you want the pretty pictures, see my original Golden Steer NYC review. This one’s about the food.
The Salads: Yes, Two of Them
I was there with a group, just chilling, and we started with two salads: the wedge and the Golden Steer dinner salad.
I know. I KNOW what you’re going to say. “Roman, where’s the tableside Caesar?” Listen. We’d been eating all day. This would have been our third salad of the day. Sometimes you just want a wedge. You can’t always have Caesars. Variety is the spice of life, and life needs fiber.



The Appetizers: Tartare, the New Escargot, and a Crab Cake
For appetizers, we went traditional, with one new face.
The steak tartare. You know me. I’m one of the biggest fans of their steak tartare. It’s a solid, solid dish. Well flavored, a little fatty, a little spice, and perfectly balanced. If you only get one classic appetizer here, it’s this.
The escargot bourguignonne is new on the fall menu, and it earned its spot. Big puffs of pastry, and the amount of garlic butter was perfect. Enough to soak everything, not so much that you’re swimming in it. Balanced. Welcome to the team.
And the crab cake? Spectacular. Really, really good.
Now, my cardiologist is going to have notes. But hey, at least I had a salad. A real salad. Not a carrot cake.



The Oyster Shooters You Need to Try
Before the steaks landed, we ordered a round of oyster shooters for the table. You have to try these. Think of an oyster dropped into a spicy, savory tomato juice situation. Sounds strange. Tastes great. It’s a little jolt of energy before you commit to several pounds of beef, and a group toast that actually means something: we’re about to eat a lot.
The Steaks: Ribeye and Porterhouse
For entrees, we went with a ribeye and a Porterhouse. Both perfect. Solid, beautifully cooked, everything you want from the steakhouse that sits at #1 on my Best Steakhouses in NYC list. No notes. Just chewing.
I also picked up a bottle of Sergio’s Seasoning, their house salt and pepper blend. I put it on everything at home now. Eggs. Chicken. My feelings. Everything.



The New Sides: Butternut Squash and Brussels Sprouts
You can’t do a fall menu without fall sides, and Golden Steer added two new ones.
The butternut squash is basically autumn on a plate. Warm, sweet, cozy, and the closest thing to a vegetable my cardiologist will believe I ate.
And then there were the Brussels sprouts with apples and bacon. These were amazing. Crispy, sweet from the apples, smoky and salty from the bacon. The best of the new dishes, if you ask me. The kind of side that makes you forget there’s a tomahawk on the table. Almost.
I’d show you a picture, but by that point I was too many martinis in to take a good photo. You’ll have to trust me on this one. Or better yet, go order them and take a better picture than I could.



Dessert: This Is What Everybody Came For
Now for the part everyone actually wanted.
We got the new pumpkin pie spice cheesecake. Rich, hearty, solid. Fall in a slice, and a strong debut.
We got the Casino Royale cake, a five-layer chocolate cake with ganache, hazelnut crunch, and espresso caramel. Super rich. Perfect for every one of your friends who is obsessed with chocolate. You know who you are.
And of course, the bananas Foster, flambĂ©ed tableside, because if something isn’t on fire at Golden Steer, are you even there?
I have no idea how we finished most of this. It was basically our fourth meal of the day. But we did. Champions.



A Second Visit, and Full Transparency
Separately, a friend treated me to a tasting at Golden Steer. We got a little bit of everything: a full board of lobster, steaks, the works. And as always, everything was spectacular.
Since I praise this place so often, I want to be upfront. I pay for my meals here way more often than not. Sometimes I get a free drink or two. That’s it. I’m not on the payroll. I just love the place. And I love their martini menu. Obviously.
The Verdict
As always, Golden Steer was spectacular, and the new fall dishes fit right in. I’m always praising it, and I’ll keep praising it until it gives me a reason not to. I’ll probably be back soon when my buddy from Florida is in town. He’s a chef, and he lives for this kind of meal.
If you haven’t been, go. If you’ve been, go back for the fall menu. Get the tartare, order the oyster shooters, don’t skip the Brussels sprouts, and save room for the pumpkin pie spice cheesecake. Or don’t save room. Just make room. That’s what winter is for.
As always, what do I know? I am just a fat guy from Brooklyn trying to survive the week, one martini at a time.
Looking for more NYC restaurant reviews? Check out my Best Steakhouses in NYC, Best Burgers in NYC, and Best Restaurants in NYC lists.