Las Vegas sent New York two steakhouses. One showed up in a vintage tux with a pinky ring. The other showed up in a sharp blazer, top button undone, holding a martini it pulled out of the freezer.
I have now eaten at Golden Steer four times and Carversteak twice. That is six Vegas steakhouse dinners, which my doctor would call “a pattern” and I call “research.” Somebody had to settle this. It might as well be the guy who already owns the pants with the forgiving waistband.
Two Vegas imports. Six rounds. One winner. No refunds.
The Quick Answer
- Best overall: Golden Steer
- Best steak: Golden Steer
- Best Caesar: Golden Steer, and it is not close
- Best burger: Carversteak
- Best for a fun night with friends: Carversteak
- Best solo bar seat: Golden Steer
- Best value: Golden Steer, because the lobster tails are the size of my head
In This Corner: Golden Steer (Old Vegas)
Golden Steer has been a Las Vegas legend for decades, and the New York outpost brought the good Vegas with it. Not new-money neon Vegas. The polished, intentional, cool-without-trying Vegas your grandfather lied to you about. The room is green and classic with cowboy accents, roulette-table vibes and dice details everywhere. It is playful but classy. Nostalgia without the tackiness.
I have been back so many times the hostess probably has a file on me. There was the first visit, the tableside Caesar and giant shrimp return, the group dinner where SevenRooms almost gave me a heart attack, and most recently the fall menu, ranked by my waistline.
In the Other Corner: Carversteak (New Vegas)
Carversteak lives inside the Civilian Hotel on 48th Street. Hop off the E at 50th and you are there before your Uber would have finished canceling on you. It opened March 20 and I was in there basically the next day, because I have no hobbies.
It comes out of Las Vegas with a slightly French-leaning steakhouse vibe. Think Boucherie, but it loosened its tie and had a martini first. Here is round one and round two.
Round One: The Steak
Golden Steer’s filet mignon is executed perfectly every time. Every. Time. The bone-in New York strip special came out perfectly cooked, and on the fall visit the ribeye and the porterhouse got the highest praise I give anything: no notes. I also walked out with a bottle of Sergio’s Seasoning, because apparently I think I can recreate this at home. I cannot.
Carversteak’s filet is a good steak. But Golden Steer has a secret weapon, and it is Sergio’s Seasoning. That stuff turns a great filet into a filet you think about on the subway ride home. Carversteak brought a knife to a seasoning fight.
Winner: Golden Steer. There is a reason it sits at number one on my Best Steakhouses in NYC list.
Round Two: The Caesar
This one is a mismatch. Golden Steer’s Caesar is number one on my Caesar salad power ranking. The waiter builds it tableside, walking through every ingredient like he is defusing a bomb made of lettuce. Three minutes of pure theater, and it tastes better because you watched it happen. Science cannot explain this. I have stopped asking.
Carversteak’s baby gem Caesar landed at number five, which is still a compliment. They separate the leaves so you are not hacking through half a head of lettuce like a survival show contestant, and the white anchovies show up like the last guest who somehow makes the party better.
Winner: Golden Steer. Carversteak made a very good salad. Golden Steer staged a production with a waiter who deserves an agent.



Round Three: The Martini
Now we are talking. My favorite category. My only category, if I am honest.
Golden Steer’s martinis are strong, cold and exactly what a steakhouse martini should be. The espresso martini at the bar is one of the three things I tell everyone to order there. On the fall visit I was too many martinis in to take a decent photo of the Brussels sprouts, which tells you everything about the martini menu and nothing good about my photography.
Carversteak treats martinis like a playground. The Freezer Door Martini lets you pick the strength, the size and the garnish. It is basically Build-A-Bear for martinis, and I mean that as the highest possible praise. There is a Pepperoncini Martini and a Shuck and Sear Martini for the adventurous. The rum-based VIP Espresso Martini was interesting but a bit too sweet for me. Round two drinks were solid too, though it was not quite the same without Brandy (with an “I”) behind the bar.
Winner: split decision. Carversteak wins on fun. Golden Steer wins on the espresso martini, and in this house the espresso martini is the tiebreaker.
Round Four: The Burger
Carversteak’s wagyu burger was ridiculous in the best way. Juicy to the point where it drips down your hands, but it still holds together just enough not to completely betray you. It is a legit Top 10 candidate for my Best Burgers in NYC list. The gooey wagyu cheesesteak riding shotgun did not hurt either.
Golden Steer’s burger has never made it into one of my posts. Ordering a burger at Golden Steer feels like going to a Sinatra show and requesting a cover band.
Winner: Carversteak, by knockout and also by forfeit.
Round Five: Sides and Dessert
Golden Steer brings a deep bench. Seasonal carrots, loaded fries, a rich twice-baked potato, and from the fall menu, Brussels sprouts with apples and bacon that were the best of the new dishes. Dessert was the pumpkin pie spice cheesecake, a super rich Casino Royale cake and bananas Foster, because winter is coming and I am preparing like a bear with a credit card.
Carversteak counters with the Crispy Fry Trio, and now we are talking. Regular fries, tater tots and sweet potato fries, with truffle aioli, ketchup and a spicy sauce for dunking. It is three sides in one basket, which is the kind of efficiency I respect. It is basically a potato sampler for people who cannot commit, and I have never committed to anything except martinis.
For dessert, Carversteak has profiteroles. I know that now. On my first visit I literally wrote it down as the “I’ll figure out the name later” special, and in my head it has been the porfritito ever since. Whatever you call it, I ate all of it.
Winner: Golden Steer, but closer than you think. The fry trio put up a real fight. Golden Steer’s bench is just deeper, and the Brussels sprouts with bacon are the difference.



Round Six: Value
Carversteak clocked in around $150 a person on round two with food, drinks and sides. In NYC terms that is basically a good deal now, which is insane but also reality.
Golden Steer’s bill depends entirely on how much self-control you walk in with. Mine is usually zero. But here is the thing: the lobster tails are the size of my head. I am not exaggerating, and I have a large head. When the shrimp cocktail is three shrimp that look like they skipped leg day at the lobster gym and the lobster tail needs its own chair, you are getting your money’s worth.
Winner: Golden Steer. Value is not what you pay. Value is how much lobster you can fit in a to-go box.
Final Verdict
Golden Steer takes four rounds, Carversteak takes one, and the martini goes to the judges. Final answer: Golden Steer wins. It stays at number one on my Best Steakhouses in NYC list and my Best Restaurants in NYC list.
But Carversteak is not the loser here. It is the fun cousin. Go for the wagyu burger, build your own freezer martini and leave feeling like you got away with something.
Golden Steer is where you take someone you want to impress. Carversteak is where you take someone you want to have fun with. If that is the same person, marry them.
As always, what do I know? I am just a fat guy from Brooklyn trying to survive the week, one martini at a time.
Looking for more NYC restaurant reviews? Check out my Best Steakhouses in NYC, Best Burgers in NYC, and Best Restaurants in NYC lists.