One of my favorite songs is “Bad Company” by Five Finger Death Punch. So when my close friend Daisy and I finally made dinner plans after not seeing each other in forever, it felt right to go the other direction. Good Company. Newly opened in SoHo. Sometimes the universe hands you the theme.
The Space
Good Company is a two-level bar slash restaurant slash entertainment space. I don’t know exactly what to call it. Two stories. And I did not want to drag my fat ass up the stairs, so I found a good spot downstairs at the bar and planted myself like a flag.
I walked in a little early, around 4:30, and the place is beautiful. Warm, lots of natural textures, greenery, the kind of room that makes you want to stay for one more drink. The drinks were great and the people were fun.
Get a Reservation. Seriously.
Here’s my number one piece of advice: make a reservation. By 5:00, pretty much every table was taken. By 5:30, it was popping in full.
The crowd is very fun and very loud. If you’re coming here to have a deep, meaningful conversation, this isn’t it. Go somewhere else for that. This is a fun night out, not a therapy session. Daisy and I had been catching up for about ten minutes before we switched to just yelling “this is good” at each other. It worked.
The Drinks: A Miso Old Fashioned and the Martini Search Continues
I started with a miso old fashioned. Savory, smooth, and a little weird in the best way. Then I switched back to martinis, which went down very fast and very easy. Too easy. Dangerously easy.
Quick moment of honesty: the Miso martini at Palladino’s was one of my favorite martinis of all time. Solid, perfect blend. And they took it off the menu. That’s neither here nor there. It is what it is. But every Miso Cocktail I drink now is secretly auditioning for that spot. Good Company’s held its own.
Daisy went with the St-Germain cocktail and loved it. She’d order it again, and she’s not really a drinker, so that’s a real endorsement.



What We Ordered
We went with a pretty standard lineup: the Caesar, grilled cheese with tomato soup, the Wagyu French dip sliders, the Good Burger, and the hot honey mustard chicken nuggets.
Yes, we’re adults. That’s exactly why we can order fancy chicken nuggets. Nobody can stop us.
Overall, the meal was pretty damn good. I didn’t love everything, but that’s just my vibe. Let’s start with what didn’t work for me, then get to the good stuff.
The Misses: Grilled Cheese, Tomato Soup, and the Sliders
The grilled cheese and tomato soup was a miss for me. When I think grilled cheese, I think soft bread with a buttery, crunchy outside. This was more of a crusty, porous bread, and the cheese wasn’t melted all the way through. And the tomato soup was bland. Just bland. That one’s a hard no for me next time.
The Wagyu French dip sliders weren’t my cup of tea either. Nothing was bad about them. The meat was good. There was just too much bread for my style. I’ve had sliders all over this city, and these just weren’t in my rotation.
The Caesar: Solid, With a Warning
The Caesar wasn’t outstanding, but I’d order it again. One warning: it’s deceptively large. The way they cut and stack everything, it piles up high, so you’re getting lots and lots of lettuce, cheese, and sauce. Share it or pace yourself.



The Hot Honey Mustard Chicken Nuggets Are the Star
Now the good stuff. The hot honey mustard chicken nuggets were spectacular. Sweet, spicy, crispy, with a good ranch on the side.
A good ranch. At Good Company. Isn’t it ironic? Don’t you think? I’ll see myself out.
Daisy and I both agreed: we’re coming back for these. If you only order one thing, order the nuggets. You’re an adult. You’ve earned them.



The Good Burger: Where Have I Had You Before?
And then the Good Burger. I spent most of dinner trying to figure out where I’d had this burger before, because it tastes like an homage to something. An old school classic. Red onion, dill pickles, white cheddar, and a good sauce. With the number of burgers I’ve eaten, I’m not going to remember all of them, so it’s going to haunt me. Maybe the Yesterday’s team knows something. Maybe it’s just a really good classic burger. Either way, it’s solid.
The cut looks great. It’s not one of those overly saturated Wagyu situations. It eats like good American beef with enough meat to matter. Honestly, it might be taking over a spot on my Best Burgers in NYC list. Might. I need a second date.
The nuggets and the burger are going to be our go-to order here.
The Verdict
I like Good Company. Fun crowd, beautiful room, great drinks, a staff that’s very knowledgeable about what they’re serving, and two dishes I’d come back for in a heartbeat. I’d try more of the menu too. Just not the tomato soup. That’s a no. That’s just me.
It came out to about $100 a person for food and drinks, which is not bad for New York, especially in SoHo.
Good Company? Good company. The Five Finger Death Punch fans in my life will be disappointed I didn’t find the bad kind. I’m okay with that.
As always, what do I know? I am just a fat guy from Brooklyn trying to survive the week, one martini at a time.
Looking for more NYC restaurant reviews? Check out my Best Steakhouses in NYC, Best Burgers in NYC, and Best Restaurants in NYC lists.